A ceremony marking the building's rededication as the Sixth & I Historic Synagogue for use by the Jewish community was held on April 22, 2004, filling the sanctuary to capacity. The theme of the rededication was "From Generation to Generation."

The program included a welcome by Rory Zuckerman of the Sixth & I Planning Committee and was hosted by Steve Buckhantz, the "voice of the Washington Wizards."

Music was provided by the Capitol Duo (flutist Cristina Burack and bassoonist Libby Miles); the Turner Memorial A.M.E. Church choir, vocalist Mark Novak, Washington Hebrew Congregation cantor Mikhail Manevich and cellist Neale Perl, president of the Washington Performing Arts Society, accompanied by Andrew Rosenblum. Three shofarot were sounded by Police chaplain Colin Alter and Natasha and Misha Shangold.

Speakers at the Rededication (from left) included Washington, DC Delegate to Congress Eleanor Holmes Norton; synagogue co-founders Abe Pollin, Douglas Jemal and Shelton Zuckerman; District of Columbia Mayor Anthony Williams; His Excellency, Ambassador of Israel Daniel Ayalon; the Reverend Darryl E. Walker of Turner Memorial A.M.E. Church; and Rabbi Stanley Rabinowitz. Photos on this page by Carrie Devorah.